Image by Caravaggio, murdering fuckhead
We made a change to the Daphne shortlist. We removed David Irving’s Destruction in Dresden in favor of Jessica Mitford’s The American Way of Death.
I have a… standard, let’s call it. I believe that it’s important to separate the art from the artist, but only when they are dead. When artists are raping or beating their wives and still up and around, I am of the opinion that you should not give them your money or support. Part of it is because of this here. Do I want that artist that I happen to like who murdered his wife and got away with it to have more money to do things with and enjoy his life? Do I want to express my value to him in the form of cash? No, not really. And it’s not like someone like Woody Allen needs my money at this point, but it’s the principle of the thing. My money is finite, I’ll give it to someone who isn’t an asshole.
Because of all that, letting Destruction in Dresden onto the shortlist, given that its author is a Holocaust denying fuckhead (alleged! He sues!) and is still alive, was a difficult decision to make. And I never quite felt okay with it, as much as I admire the book. After a couple conversations, and then bringing it to a vote with the nonfiction panelists, we decided to remove the book after all. And replace it with a Mitford, whose family knows all about being fuckheads, but okay. (That’s a really nice top you’ve got on, Unity, where’d you get it? It’s so cute, oh my god, really? Really, Unity Mitford?) Jessica was a tough babe, she’ll be fine.
I still think there’s an interesting conversation to be had around Destruction in Dresden, but maybe we’ll do it without the book in play. Stan Carey, one of our panelists, recommended Gregory Bateson’s Steps to an Ecology of Mind, which also discusses how we turn other people into something less than human, and don’t regret wiping them out.
As a result of all this, the Daphne Awards, which would have been announced May-ish, will probably have to be pushed back a little, we had a new book to order and distribute. (And read. And debate.) We’ll keep you posted.